LCQ2: Preventing fraud involving use of Subscriber Identification Module cards

     Following is a question by the Hon Grace Chan and a reply by the Acting Secretary for Commerce and Economic Development, Dr Bernard Chan, in the Legislative Council today (November 18):
 
Question:
 
     It has been reported that some people hand over registered Subscriber Identification Module (SIM) cards to fraud syndicates through various means. As renting or selling SIM cards is not an offence, the registered holder of a SIM card may use ignorance as an excuse to evade criminal liability for fraud. In this connection, will the Government inform this Council:
 
(1) whether it has studied the common methods by which real-name registered SIM cards fall into the hands of fraud syndicates, and assessed the standard of proof and feasible approaches for establishing that the registered holders of the SIM cards have committed fraud;
 
(2) as the Government indicated last year that it would introduce a bill into this Council this year to combat the misuse of SIM cards, of the relevant progress; whether it will introduce administrative measures prior to enacting legislation to plug the relevant loopholes, such as requiring telecommunications operators to verify cases involving a large number of SIM card registrations within a short period or frequent changes of registered holders; and
 
(3) as it is learnt that some jurisdictions prevent fraud through the approach of shifting responsibility upstream (i.e. requiring the party with the greatest capacity for risk management to bear the responsibility for prevention), including imposing criminal liability on persons who hand over SIM cards to fraud syndicates and restricting them from registering new SIM cards, or requiring financial institutions to share the losses arising from fraud, whether the authorities will consider introducing the principle of responsibility allocation, as well as launching a public consultation on the loss-sharing mechanism and including this in the scope of the study on legislative amendments?
 
Reply:
 
President,
 
     The Office of the Communications Authority (OFCA) has been working closely with the Hong Kong Police Force (Police) and major telecommunications service providers (TSPs), and has implemented a number of measures from the telecommunications perspective to combat telephone fraud through the collaboration among the Government, business sector and the public. In response to the question raised by the Hon Grace Chan, and in consultation with the Security Bureau, the Financial Services and the Treasury Bureau (FSTB) and OFCA, the consolidated reply is as follows:
 
     According to investigations and analysis by the Police, fraud syndicates routinely use financial incentives as bait to recruit mule registrants, instructing them to purchase and register batches of physical SIM cards at retail outlets with their own identities, and then pass these SIM cards to other members of the fraud syndicates. The fraud syndicates would then connect multiple physical SIM cards to a telephone modem and computer system commonly known as "modem pool" to make or send a large number of fraudulent calls or phishing text messages within a short period of time. In cases involving the use of SIM cards to commit fraud, the Police generally brings charges under fraud, obtaining property by deception and obtaining services by deception, etc, of the Theft Ordinance (Cap. 210).
 
     Having regard to the analysis of telephone fraud provided by the Police and the operational experience since the full implementation of the Real-name Registration Programme for SIM Cards in 2023, the Government proposes to criminalise certain improper conduct of using SIM cards, such as provision of personal information for the registration of a SIM card intended for use by another person as well as purchase, sale, rental, borrowing or other activities involving supply or acquisition of registered SIM cards without lawful authority or reasonable excuse or justification. This proposal will prevent fraud syndicates from using SIM cards registered under others' identities to commit telephone fraud, and will also deter members of the public from providing their personal information or registered SIM cards to unknown individuals. Furthermore, we propose lowering the maximum registration limit of the number of pre-paid SIM (PPS) cards for individual users from the existing limit of 10 PPS cards per TSP per person to three PPS cards per TSP per person, which will help minimise the risks of PPS cards being exploited by criminals for fraudulent purposes. The Government is actively preparing the details for legislative amendments and plans to consult the public and the industry on the proposals as soon as possible in the coming months. Upon completion of the relevant legislative amendments, we envisage that a more targeted legal framework will be in place to combat activities involving illegal lease or sale of registered SIM cards, thereby lowering the standard of proof and enhancing the effectiveness of law enforcement.
 
     At present, OFCA has required the TSPs to step up monitoring and conduct further verification of users who have registered PPS cards approaching the current registration limit. If users subject to sample checks are unable to verify the registration information in accordance with the instructions of the TSPs, the relevant PPS cards will be deregistered and rendered invalid. The TSPs have conducted multiple rounds of verification since February 2023, resulting in the cancellation of approximately 4.2 million PPS card registrations due to non-compliance with verification requirements. The TSPs will also refer cases of suspected fraud or impersonation identified during the process for handling by the Police. According to the analysis of statistics provided by the TSPs, the vast majority (about 98 per cent) of individual users have currently registered no more than three PPS cards with each TSP. The TSPs will continue to closely monitor abnormal patterns of SIM card registration and usage, suspend relevant telephone services where necessary, and refer suspicious cases to the Police for follow-up.
 
     As for the banking sector, the Hong Kong Monetary Authority (HKMA), in collaboration with the Police and the Hong Kong Association of Banks, launched the Financial Intelligence Evaluation Sharing Tool in June 2023, providing the banking industry with a secure and efficient electronic platform to exchange business accounts information suspected to be related to financial crimes, and its scope of information exchange was expanded in December 2025 to cover suspicious individual accounts. The HKMA also introduced new measures, "E-Banking Security ABCD", in August 2025, requiring banks to further enhance protection for their banking customers through "Authenticate in-App", "Bye to unused functions", "Cancel suspicious payments" and "Deepfake detection". In addition, the FSTB is exploring to enhance the legal framework to bolster detection and removal of content relating to financial fraud by different sectors such as technology and telecommunications. The FSTB plans to launch a public consultation on the proposed legal framework by the end of this year.
 
     Regarding how banks handle claims for fraud losses arising from authorised payment transactions by customers, the HKMA consulted the banking industry last year. Taking into account the feedback received and other relevant developments, the HKMA will further explore how each relevant party's responsibility in frauds should be determined and the arrangements for handling customers' claims for fraud losses.
 
     Telephone fraud tactics are constantly evolving. The Government will continue to adopt a cross-departmental, collaborative approach to fortify defences on all fronts. However, public awareness of fraud prevention is also crucial. The Government will therefore continue to step up anti-fraud publicity and education, and build a comprehensive and robust anti-deception system from multiple perspectives. Thank you, President.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.