Following is a question by the Hon Chan Hoi-yan and a written reply by the Secretary for Health, Professor Lo Chung-mau, in the Legislative Council today (November 18):
Question:
The Dental Council of Hong Kong (DCHK) is a statutory body established under the Dentists Registration Ordinance. It is responsible for, inter alia, the registration and disciplinary control of dentists and dental care professionals in Hong Kong. My office has recently received successive requests for assistance, in which complainants alleged that after lodging complaints with DCHK, they had waited for a long time without receiving confirmation from DCHK as to whether their complaints had been accepted for further processing. In some of these cases, the complainants have even waited for more than a year, with the complaints still at the stage of consideration by the Chairperson of the Preliminary Investigation Committee (PIC) (initial consideration). In this connection, will the Government inform this Council:
(1) whether it knows the respective numbers of cases currently backlogged at DCHK and PIC;
(2) whether it knows the current staff establishment of the DCHK Secretariat responsible for handling complaints and the specific duties performed by the relevant staff upon receipt of a complaint;
(3) whether it knows, in each of the past five years, the number of complaints received by DCHK and, among such complaints, the respective numbers of those which were decided not to be proceeded with further after initial consideration, those for which PIC decided, after processing, that no inquiry was warranted, and those requiring a formal inquiry after processing;
(4) whether it knows, in each of the past five years, the respective average and longest time taken by DCHK to process complaints from receipt of a complaint to the completion of the initial consideration and the PIC stage of the complaint;
(5) whether it knows, in each of the past five years, the respective numbers of complaints the handling of which was completed by DCHK, broken down by the time taken to complete the processing, namely, within (i) one year, (ii) one to two years, (iii) two to three years, (iv) three to four years, (v) four to five years, and (vi) more than five years; and
(6) whether the Government has any plans to enhance the efficiency and transparency of DCHK in handling complaints; if so, of the details and timetable; if not, the reasons for that?
Reply:
President,
The healthcare professions in Hong Kong uphold the principle of professional autonomy. The Dental Council of Hong Kong (DCHK) is a statutory regulatory body established under the Dentists Registration Ordinance (Cap. 156) (Ordinance). It discharges various functions in accordance with the law, including handling the registration of dentists and dental care professionals (DCPs), conducting licensing examinations, formulating professional codes and guidelines, and exercising disciplinary regulation over dentists and DCPs registered in Hong Kong. The DCHK has always been committed to upholding the professional conduct and discipline of dentists and DCPs, as well as raising their professional standards, in order to protect the rights and interests of the public and raise public confidence in the dental profession.
Handling complaints against dentists and DCPs is one of the important functions of the DCHK. The DCHK currently has two Preliminary Investigation Committees (PICs) responsible for carrying out investigation into complaints received. Upon receipt of a complaint or information alleging any registered dentist or DCP to have breached the professional code formulated by the DCHK, to have been convicted in Hong Kong or elsewhere of any offence punishable with imprisonment, or to have been involved in other misconduct, the Secretary to the DCHK will, in accordance with the provisions of the Dentists (Registration and Disciplinary Procedure) Regulations, submit the information provided by the complainant to the Chairperson of the PIC for preliminary consideration (initial consideration) to decide whether the case should be proceeded with further. Subsequently, as directed by the Chairperson of the PIC, the Secretary will request the complainant to provide relevant medical records, statutory declarations and other information, etc to assist in the investigation. If the PIC considers there to be sufficient information indicating that the dentist or DCP concerned may have fallen short of the required professional conduct, it will refer the case to the DCHK for holding a disciplinary inquiry.
In response to the question raised by the Hon Chan Hoi-yan, having consulted the DCHK Secretariat, the consolidated reply is as follows:
Progress of handling complaints
In the past five years (i.e. 2021 to 2025), the number of complaints received by the DCHK ranged from 160 to 220 each year. As of October 31, 2026, there were 203 complaint cases still being processed by the DCHK.
Between 2021 and 2026 (as of October 31), the DCHK has completed the handling of 980 complaint cases, of which about 70 per cent were completed within one year upon receipt of the complaint, and nearly 95 per cent were completed within three years. Broken down by processing stage, among the 980 cases, 814 cases were decided not to be proceeded with further after initial consideration by the Chairperson of the PIC for being frivolous or groundless; 129 cases were decided by the PIC after consideration that no inquiry was warranted; 31 cases were referred to the DCHK for inquiry with the complaints substantiated; and six cases were found unsubstantiated after inquiry by the DCHK.
Among the above cases, the median time taken from the receipt of a complaint to completing initial consideration was five months; the median time taken from completing initial consideration to the PIC's decision on whether a referral to the DCHK for holding a disciplinary inquiry was required was 17 months; and the median time taken for the DCHK to conduct a disciplinary inquiry was 15 months. Individual cases of a more complex nature might require a longer processing time due to reasons such as the need for complainants to supplement relevant case information and documents, the need for the PIC/DCHK to study relevant medical records in detail, seeking legal advice and the need to seek dental expert reports.
Relevant data are set out in the Annex.
Staff establishment of the DCHK Secretariat
The current staff establishment of the DCHK Secretariat is set out below. It also employs four contract clerical staff. The relevant personnel provide administrative support to the DCHK and assist the DCHK in performing various statutory functions, including handling complaints against dentists and DCPs, such as preparing relevant documents, requesting complainants to provide relevant medical records and statutory declarations as directed by the Chairperson of the PIC, and (if necessary) seeking dental expert reports as directed by the DCHK.
| Rank | Number |
| Chief Executive Officer | 1 (Note) |
| Senior Executive Officer | 2 |
| Executive Officer I | 2 |
| Executive Officer II/Hospital Administrator II | 2 |
| Clerical Officer | 2 |
| Assistant Clerical Officer | 1 |
| Total | 10 |
Note: The Chief Executive Officer is the Secretary to the DCHK, who is responsible for supervising the work of the DCHK Secretariat and is concurrently responsible for other duties relating to the Medical Council of Hong Kong and the Boards and Councils Office.
Enhancing the efficiency of handling complaints
The Legislative Council passed the amendments to the Ordinance in July 2024, which included amending the composition and structure of the DCHK, allowing the establishment of more than one PIC and the inclusion of lay members in the committee, to ensure the complaint investigation and disciplinary procedures are more efficient and credible, and better protect public interests. Following the legislative amendments, the DCHK has established a second PIC and plans to appoint a second Legal Adviser in early 2027 to assist in handling complaints and providing legal advice. The above measures can help expedite the handling of complaint cases.
In the Chief Executive's 2026 Policy Address, it was announced that the Government will raise the manpower and system support for healthcare professional regulatory bodies. The Department of Health (DH) will increase resources to enhance administrative and professional support for various boards and councils (including the DCHK), including support for the relevant complaint handling systems, to better ensure that the conduct of healthcare professionals meets public expectations. At the same time, the DH will continue to communicate with the DCHK to support the DCHK in enhancing the efficiency and transparency of complaint handling under the existing legal framework, and will review the service quality of the Secretariat as appropriate. Through various measures, including increasing the use of information technology and optimising the organisational structure, the DH will enhance the operational efficiency of the Secretariat to better support the DCHK in performing its statutory functions.